|
|
Post by Cannman on Jun 11, 2004 19:09:17 GMT -4
I am Caper
While i liked the Pick the Hottie poll, i think you should have a greatest hockey player poll. Maybe greatest goalie or greatest team (by year; example: 1989 Calgary Flames vs. 2004 Tampa Bay Lightning) because we know everyone would pick the Leafs. Ha ha. Now, I, as a member of the Caper Corner, have spoken. Move your ass, beotch and make it happen...please.
Cannman
|
|
|
|
Post by IAMCAPER on Jun 11, 2004 21:42:54 GMT -4
I think this is a great idea but it poses a particular problem. In order to do a poll on who is the greatest hockey player of all time, or which team was the best of all time, I would have to first decide who the top, say, 64 players/teams are of all time and then pit them against one another. The problem with this is that it is open to my interpretation and my list of the top 64 players/teams will most likely be different from everybody elses top 64 players/teams of all time. So basically, we would be voting on who is the best out the players that I think are the best of all time. I do have 2 suggestions to work around this though.
First, we could ask that everybody submit a list of their top 50 players of all time and from those lists we will determine a collective top 64 and go from there. Or, and this is my personal favourite, we could find out who is the best player from 32 entry drafts, say from the years 58 to 90, and then have our tournament out of those players. The members would first pick the best player from each draft and then the tournament would take place from there.
Any comments or suggestions on this idea?
|
|
